Facebook under fire for posts on auction of child bride

November 23, 2018 Newsbeat, Stories

Facebook has come under fire after posts discussing the sale of a child bride were made and shared on its site.

By Bianca Britton, CNN

Nov 23, 2018(SSNN) — An auction was discussed on the social media platform for a girl aged 16 or 17 in South Sudan that sought payment for her hand in marriage.

Facebook said the post was taken down as soon as the company learned of it, but that wasn’t until after the girl involved was married.

According to children’s rights organization Plan International, the girl was bid on by five men, some of whom were reportedly high-ranking South Sudanese government officials.

Activists are concerned that this auction — for which the father reportedly received 500 cows, three cars and $10,000 in exchange for his daughter — could inspire other families to use social media sites to receive larger payments.

Plan International’s country director in South Sudan, George Otim, said: “That a girl could be sold for marriage on the world’s biggest social networking site in this day and age is beyond belief.”

He added: “This barbaric use of technology is reminiscent of latter-day slave markets.”

‘It just went viral’

emerged photos of the wedding ceremony of a 17-year-old South Sudanese girl, Nyalong Ngong Deng Jalang, looking downcast on her wedding day(Photo credit: 60sec9janews.)

South Sudanese human rights lawyer Phillips Ngong told CNN the auction took place in person and not on Facebook.

Ngong said the family had no intention of posting to Facebook, but the dowry amount pledged for her was higher than usual and generated a lot of discussion among Facebook members.

“In South Sudan, Facebook and social media is a brand new thing. Someone just took a picture. And it just went viral,” he added.

Though Facebook said the post was taken down on November 9, posts discussing the dowry were still live on Friday, November 23.

These posts discussed the price being offered for the girl by the highest bidder, as well as how much Facebook users would offer for her. CNN has flagged these two live posts to Facebook, which has yet to issue comment.

The man who won the bidding for the teenager, businessman Kok Alat, did not find out about the girl through Facebook, Ngong said. CNN has reached out to Kok Alat as well as the girl’s family for comment.

But the marriage of the girl is still egregious, Ngong said, particularly as a state government official is believed to be among the bidders. Ngong said it was a direct violation of child marriage laws by those in power: “Anything that happens that is not in the best interest of the child is a violation. And the constitution and child laws are very clear on that.”

South Sudan’s Constitution states that marriage requires the “free and full consent” of those intending to marry. A child is defined as anyone under the age of 18, according to the country’s Child Act, 2008, which adds that “every child has the right to be protected from early marriage.”

Removed from Facebook

Facebook said in a statement to CNN that any form of “human trafficking — whether posts, pages, ads or groups is not allowed on Facebook.”

“We removed the post and permanently disabled the account belonging to the person who posted this to Facebook,” a company spokesperson said in a statement.

“We’re always improving the methods we use to identify content that breaks our policies, including doubling our safety and security team to more than 30,000 and investing in technology,” the spokesperson added.

Otim from Plan International told CNN that offering payments is part of the country’s culture, but that in this case it “was taken to another level because of technology.”

The South Sudanese National Alliance for Women Lawyers (NAWL) told CNN that the auction was not posted by her family, but by someone from the community instead, and that the family benefited from the bidding war.

“A few of our colleagues were able to get in touch with the mother (of the bride) and she was not happy about it,” said Suzy Natana, a lawyer at NAWL.

As problems pile up, Mark Zuckerberg stands his ground in exclusive CNN Business interview

She added that the marriage took place on November 3, 2018, according to locals the association spoke with.

Natana said that this is the highest bride price that has been reported in the region. She added that NAWL is against the process of bidding because “it makes you more of a commodity instead of a human being.”

An organization focused on gender equality, Equality Now, called on Facebook to improve its monitoring practices.

“Violations against women in South Sudan are a continuing issue, but for Facebook to allow their platform to enhance these violations is a problem,” said Judy Gitau, Equality Now’s regional coordinator for Africa.

She told CNN that Facebook has a responsibility to uphold women’s rights, and added: “They ought to put in place more human resources to monitor their platform to ensure that women’s rights, and indeed the rights of all people, are protected.”

Call on government to investigate officials

Plan International has also called on the South Sudanese government to investigate and suspend any officials involved in the bridal auction.

“Child marriage is a serious violation of human rights and a form of violence against girls,” Otim from the group said in a statement.

“It can have profound consequences on a child’s survival, health, education, development and well-being and is often carried out against their will and best interests.”

Otim told CNN the solution for preventing child marriages is to try to keep girls in school, but admits it “requires a lot of effort to change” the culture.

According to UNICEF’s November 2017 figures, 52% of girls in South Sudan are married before they turn 18.

The United Nations’ agency, which aids the world’s needy children, says that the country’s high levels of poverty, instability and gender gap fuel child marriage — with both girls and their families feeling it can help them escape poverty.

CNN’s Lauren Kent, David McKenzie and Samuel Burke contributed to this report.